I feel like the video game Bully is super overrated. I've played it when it first came out and I've tried replaying it twice once on Xbox 360 and once on iOS, and every time I feel like this game is very boring and repetitive. It's very basic compared to even the early GTA games. Go there fetch this. There is barely any variety of the gameplay. The plot is completely unremarkable. The protagonist is not likable.
If I was to compare this to another game released around this time and also set in high school, Persona 3. Yes they're completely different genres Bully is an action game and P3 is a JRPG, but if you compare replay value and just pure fun to be had with the game, I would vote Persona 3 any single day of the week. I have come back to Persona 3 multiple times, and enjoyed every single one of them.
Anyway, just my little rant here.