Agora Road Book Club: Confederacy of Dunces Edition

Favorite Book Cover

  • Jihad Edition

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Gardner Books Edition

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • German Edition

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Revenge of the Conjura Edition

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    5

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
It's been a while hasn't it? Sorry for the delay, rough last month since I moved to a new country, anyways the OP is finally here...

Confederacy of Dunces by John Kennedy Toole.

Inatius Jacques Reilly is an overweight and unemployed thirty-year-old with a master's degree in Medieval History who lives with his mother, Irene Reilly. He utterly loathes the world around him, which he feels has lost the values of geometry and theology.

About John Kennedy Toole. (Redacted from wikipedia plss no bully, there wasn't a cool Britannica post for this one)

Toole was born to John Dewey Toole, Jr. and Thelma Ducoing Toole. Kennedy was the name of Thelma's grandmother. The first of the Creole Ducoing family arrived in Louisiana from France in the early 19th century, and the Tooles immigrated to America from Ireland during the Great Famine of the 1840s. As a child, Toole had an intense affection for his black nursemaid Beulah Matthews, who cared for him when his parents were both working.

Toole's highly cultured mother was a controlling woman, especially with her son. His father was less involved and sometimes complained of his lack of influence in their child's upbringing. Despite this, he and his father bonded through a mutual interest in baseball and cars. Toole's mother chose the friends he could associate with, and felt his cousins on his father's side were too common for him to be around. Toole received high marks in elementary school and, from a young age, expressed a desire to excel academically. He skipped ahead a grade, from first to second, after taking an IQ test at the age of six, and would also eventually skip the fourth grade.

Although an excellent student, Toole curtailed his stage work when he entered high school (Alcée Fortier High), to concentrate on his academic work.[ He wrote for the school newspaper Silver and Blue, worked on the yearbook The Tarpon, and won several essay contests on subjects such as the Louisiana Purchase and the American Merchant Marine. He took up debating, a skill his father had used to win the state debate championship when he was in high school. Toole spoke at gatherings of civic organizations such as Kiwanis and Rotary Clubs. Toole became the editor of the news section of the school newspaper, and maintained high marks throughout high school. He was one of two New Orleanians voted outstanding citizen at the Pelican (now Louisiana) Boys State convention and he was invited back to serve the following year as a counsellor. He received a full scholarship to Tulane University at age 17.

During his senior year, Toole wrote The Neon Bible, a short novel of Southern Gothic fiction that has been compared in style to Flannery O'Connor, a favorite author of Toole's. Toole later described the novel during correspondence with an editor, "In 1954, when I was 16, I wrote a book called The Neon Bible, a grim, adolescent, sociological attack upon the hatreds caused by the various Calvinist religions in the South—and the fundamentalist mentality is one of the roots of what was happening in Alabama, etc. The book, of course, was bad, but I sent it off a couple of times anyway."It failed to attract interest from publishers and was not released until after Toole's death.

At Tulane he first majored in engineering on the recommendation of his father; however, after a few weeks, he changed his major to English, stating "I'm losing my culture" to his mother in explanation. His closest friend was guitarist Don Stevens, nicknamed "Steve Cha-Cha", with whom he bonded over their shared love of blues music and Beat poets. Stevens also had a side job pushing a hot tamale cart around town and, on days when he was unavailable for work, Toole would fill in for him. According to Stevens' bandmate Sidney Snow, Toole loved eating the tamales. Toole later used these experiences as material for his novel A Confederacy of Dunces, whose protagonist Ignatius J. Reilly pushes a hot dog cart around town, usually eating most of the profits. Also, like Reilly, Toole later worked at a family business that manufactured men's clothing, Haspel Brothers. He worked for J.B. Tonkel, who married one of the Haspel daughters. "Ken watched the Haspels' business dealings with great interest, absorbing and remembering their troubles and intrigues,"and he later constructed the similar Levy Pants Company in Dunces, with Gus Levy and his wife becoming significant supporting characters in the novel.

Toole returned home in 1959 to spend a year as assistant professor of English at the University of Southwestern Louisiana (USL). It was at USL that Toole met Bob Byrne, an eccentric English professor who is considered one of the primary inspirations for the character of Ignatius J. Reilly. Byrne specialized in the medieval period, and he and Toole frequently discussed the philosopher Boethius and the wheel of Fortuna, as described in Boethius' Consolation of Philosophy. Boethius was the favorite philosopher of Ignatius J. Reilly, who frequently referred to Fortuna and Consolation of Philosophy. Like Ignatius, Byrne was a self-admitted devoted slob who played the lute, and also wore a deerstalker hunting cap, which Toole frequently chided him about.

Toole's studies were interrupted by his being drafted into the United States Army in 1961. Toole (who was fluent in Spanish) served two years at Fort Buchanan in Puerto Rico, teaching English to Spanish-speaking recruits. He rose quickly in the military ranks. In under a year, he attained the rank of sergeant, and received numerous awards and citations. While serving in Puerto Rico, he frequently traveled throughout the Caribbean, either alone or with members of his company. Toole, however, began to dread the frustrations of military life and the oppressive heat of Puerto Rico.

He also engaged in one of the favorite activities of military personnel on the island: alcohol consumption. Toole remarked in another letter to Fletcher, "We are all rotting here at the moment. The decreased draft has meant no trainees since June ... the inactivity here, coupled with the remnants of a rainy and enervating summer has (have?) plunged the English instructors into an abyss of drinking and inertia. Occasionally someone will struggle off to the beach or to San Juan, but the maxim here remains, 'It's too hot.'

Due to an incident in the army where a gay instructor attempted suicide Toole became withdrawn and began spending more and more time in his office typing what would eventually become his master work, A Confederacy of Dunces. It was not a secret that Toole was writing a book. Late at night, his fellow soldiers could often hear the sound of the typewriter keys. Although he was secretive about the novel among the other men, Toole showed the early portions of it to Kubach who gave him positive feedback.Around this time, Kubach was transferred and took his typewriter with him, so Toole was forced to buy his own. He later commented that he began to "talk and act like Ignatius" during this period as he became more and more immersed in the creation of the book.

Toole received a hardship discharge as his parents were having difficult economic times, his father struggling with deafness and an increasing incidence of irrational fear and paranoia. Toole looked forward to coming home and spending time talking with his mother. Toole turned down an offer to return to his post at Hunter, and arrived home to a teaching position at Dominican College, a Catholic all-female school. He initially liked the position as it allowed him to teach for only 10.5 hours a week and afforded him the same leisure time he had during his less active periods in the service. The nuns on the faculty were enamored with Toole from the start, considering him well mannered, genteel, and charming. He used his free time to work on his novel, and to spend some time with his musician friend Sidney Snow at Snow's home in the Irish Channel and at various night clubs where he would watch Snow and his bandmates perform, among other things, covers of songs by The Beatles. The November 1963 assassination of John F. Kennedy caused Toole to fall into severe depression. He stopped writing and drank heavily. In February 1964 he resumed writing, at which point he added an ending and sent the manuscript to Simon & Schuster.

The book eventually reached senior editor Robert Gottlieb, who had talked the then-unknown Joseph Heller into completing the classic comic novel Catch-22. Gottlieb and Toole began a two-year correspondence and dialogue over the novel which would ultimately result in bitter disappointment on both sides. While Gottlieb felt Toole was undoubtedly talented, he was unhappy with the book in its original form. He felt that it had one basic flaw which he expressed to Toole in an early letter:

It seems that you understand the problem—the major problem—involved, but think that the conclusion can solve it. More is required, though. Not only do the various threads need resolving; they can always be tied together conveniently. What must happen is that they must be strong and meaningful all the way through—not merely episodic and then wittily pulled together to make everything look as if it's come out right. In other words, there must be a point to everything you have in the book, a real point, not just amusingness that's forced to figure itself out.

Toole made an unannounced trip to see editor Robert Gottlieb in person at the Simon & Schuster building in New York City in February 1965. When he found out Gottlieb was out of town, Toole felt humiliated.

Initially, although Toole was disappointed that the novel could not be published as is, he was exuberant that a major publisher was interested in it. He entered his second year of teaching at Dominican as one of the favorite new professors on staff. Students marveled at his wit, and Toole would make entire classes burst into laughter while hardly showing any expression. He never retold a story or joke, and had many repeat students. Shortly before Christmas break in 1964, Toole received a letter from Gottlieb. In it Gottlieb remarked that he had shown the novel to Candida Donadio, a literary agent whose clients included Joseph Heller and Thomas Pynchon. Gottlieb told Toole they felt he was "... wildly funny often, funnier than almost anyone around".Also they liked the same portions and characters of the book and disliked the same parts as well. Gottlieb gave a list of things he did not like concluding with:

But that, all this aside, there is another problem: that with all its wonderfulnesses, the book—even better plotted (and still better plotable)—does not have a reason; it's a brilliant exercise in invention, but unlike CATCH [22] and MOTHER KISSES and V and the others, it isn't really about anything. And that's something no one can do anything about.

Later on in the letter, Gottlieb stated that he still had faith in Toole as a writer and that he wished to hold onto the manuscript in case he or Toole would be able to see a way around his objections. Toole decided that it would be best for Gottlieb to return the manuscript, saying "Aside from a few deletions, I don't think I could really do much to the book now—and of course even with revisions you might not be satisfied." Gottlieb re-iterated that he would not accept the novel without further revision. He suggested that Toole move on to writing something else, an idea which Toole ultimately rejected.

In a long, partially autobiographical letter he sent to Gottlieb in March 1965, Toole explained that he could not give up on the book since he wrote the novel largely from personal observation and because the characters were based on real people he had seen in his life.

I don't want to throw these characters away. In other words, I'm going to work on the book again. I haven't been able to look at the manuscript since I got it back, but since something of my soul is in the thing, I can't let it rot without trying.

Toole took the rejection of the book in his intended form as a tremendous personal blow .He eventually ceased work on Dunces and for a time left it atop an armoire in his bedroom. He continued to teach at Dominican where he remained a favorite among the student body with his classes regularly filling up well before official registration. His comedic performances during lectures remained especially popular among students.

By 1967, Toole began having frequent and intense headaches, and as aspirin was no help, he saw a doctor. The doctor's treatment was also ineffective, and he suggested Toole see a neurologist, an idea which Toole rejected.

The assassinations of Robert F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King Jr. in 1968 added to his feelings of grief and heightened his paranoia. Several of Toole's longtime friends noticed he had an increasing sense of feelings of personal persecution. Toole went to see his friend Bob Byrne at his home in August 1968, where he again expressed sadness and humiliation that his book would not be published.

In the months before his suicide, Toole, who was usually extremely well groomed, "began to appear in public unshaved and uncombed, wearing unpolished shoes and wrinkled clothes, to the amazement of his friends and students in New Orleans."He also began to exhibit signs of paranoia, including telling friends that a woman who he erroneously thought had worked for Simon & Schuster was plotting to steal his book so that her husband, the novelist George Deaux, could publish it.

Toole became increasingly erratic during his lectures at Dominican, resulting in frequent student complaints, and was given to rants against church and state. Toward the end of the 1968 fall semester, he was forced to take a leave of absence and stopped attending classes at Tulane, resulting in his receiving a grade of incomplete. The Tooles spent Christmas of 1968 in disarray with Toole's father in an increasing state of dementia, and Toole searching the home for electronic mind-reading devices.

Toole was a lifelong admirer of Southern Gothic fiction writer Flannery O'Connor, and the novel The Neon Bible he wrote in high school is said to be resemblant of her writings. Shortly before his suicide, Toole attempted to visit the home of the deceased writer. Items found in Toole's car show that he drove to California where he visited Hearst Castle and then to Milledgeville, Georgia.Here he most likely attempted to visit Andalusia, the home of deceased writer Flannery O'Connor, although her house was not open to the public. This was succeeded by a drive toward New Orleans. It was during this trip that he stopped outside Biloxi, Mississippi, and died by suicide by running a garden hose from the exhaust pipe in through the window of his car on March 26, 1969. His car and person were clean, and the police officers who found him reported that his face showed no signs of distress. An envelope discovered in the car was marked "to my parents". The suicide note inside the envelope was destroyed by his mother, who later gave varying vague accounts of its details. In one instance she said it expressed his "concerned feeling for her" and later she told a Times-Picayune interviewer that the letter was "bizarre and preposterous. Violent. Ill-fated. Ill-fated. Nothing. Insane ravings."He was buried at Greenwood Cemetery in New Orleans.

After Toole's death, his mother Thelma Toole became mired in depression for two years and the manuscript for Dunces remained atop an armoire in his former room. She then became determined to have it published, believing it would be an opportunity to prove her son's talent. Over a five-year period, she sent it out to seven publishers and they each rejected it. "Each time it came back I died a little," she said. However, in 1976 she became aware that author Walker Percy was becoming a faculty member at Loyola University New Orleans. Thelma began a campaign of phone calls and letters to Percy to get him to read the manuscript. He even began complaining to his wife about a peculiar old woman's attempts to contact him. With time running out on his term as professor, Thelma pushed her way into his office and demanded he read the manuscript. Initially hesitant, Percy agreed to read the book to stop her badgering. He admitted to hoping it would be so bad that he could discard it after reading a few pages. Ultimately, he loved the book, commenting in disbelief:

In this case I read on. And on. First with the sinking feeling that it was not bad enough to quit, then with a prickle of interest, then a growing excitement, and finally an incredulity; surely it was not possible that it was so good.

Despite Percy's great admiration for the book, the road to publication was still difficult. It took more than three years, as he attempted to get several parties interested in it. A Confederacy of Dunces was published by Louisiana State University Press in 1980, and Percy provided the foreword. At his recommendation, Toole's first draft of the book was published with minimal copy-editing, and no significant revisions. The first printing was only 2,500 copies, and a number of these were sent to Scott Kramer, an executive at 20th Century Fox, to pitch around Hollywood, but the book initially generated little interest. However, the novel attracted much attention in the literary world. A year later, in 1981, Toole was posthumously awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. The book eventually sold more than 1.5 million copies, in 18 languages. In 2019, the PBS show, "The Great American Read," ranked Dunces the 58th (out of 100) most loved books in America..

101416_Toole-2_800.jpg

John_Kennedy_Toole.jpg

John-Kenedy-Toole-e1466793179714.jpg


Vote for your favorite book cover! (You can vote up to 3 times!)

20th Anniversary Edition.

Cover 01.jpg


Original Edition.

COVER 02.jpg


Jihad manual to American degeneracy edition.

cover 03.jpg


Conjura de Imbeciles Edition.

122547.jpg


Penguin Edition.
8449901.jpg


Gardner Books Edition.

24922.jpg


German Edition

19108454.jpg


Conjura de los Necios 2 Electric Bogaloo Edition.

23117599.jpg


Frenchie Edition

29760086.jpg


Penguin Paperback Edition.

117728.jpg


Ignatius O'reilly statue in New Orleans, judging your poor taste in fashion.

2468756081_216a2b8203_b.jpg


Happy Reading!

gordo-no.gif
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
Study Guides and further reading:

Note: Idk if these are spoiler free or not so use at your own discretion.

LitCharts: https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-confederacy-of-dunces
Shmoop: https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/literature/confederacy-of-dunces/summary
Super Summary: https://www.supersummary.com/confederacy-of-dunces/summary/
Course Hero: https://www.coursehero.com/lit/A-Confederacy-of-Dunces/

Further reading:

The uneasy after life of CD: https://www.newyorker.com/books/second-read/the-uneasy-afterlife-of-a-confederacy-of-dunces

Butterfly in the Typewriter: Amazon product ASIN 0306821915View: https://www.amazon.com/Butterfly-Typewriter-Kennedy-Remarkable-Confederacy/dp/0306821915


Kill all the normies: Amazon product ASIN B076TY455NView: https://www.amazon.com/Kill-All-Normies-Angela-Nagle-audiobook/dp/B076TY455N/ref=sr_1_1?crid=379K0APR4IVYN&keywords=KILL+ALL+THE+NORMIES&qid=1685379091&s=books&sprefix=kill+all+the+normie%2Cstripbooks%2C101&sr=1-1


(>Zero Books. I know, but I've heard great things about this book even from right wing figures, it's been on my to-read list for a long time)

Brick by Brick by Moviebob: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18145442-super-mario-bros-3

The Big Lebowski: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118715/ (Movie that has been compared to CD, and I def see the similarities)

Cornucopia of Dunces: Amazon product ASIN 0692572376View: https://www.amazon.com/Cornucopia-Dunderheads-CONFEDERACY-Foreword-Franz-Heinrich/dp/0692572376
(Unnoficial sequel/parody, at least according to the amazon reviews, it's actually kinda good)
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
Book Club Rules and Schedule.

The only rule is to not discuss anything past the chapters we're on without using the spoiler tag!

Week 1. June 1st to the 9th. Chapters 1 to 4

Week 2 9th to 16th. Chapters 5 to 8

Week 3. 16th to the 23rd. Chapters 9 to 12th

Week 4. June the 23rd to the 30th. Rest of the book.


What happens if I don't meet the reading deadlines?

Nothing really. You can just read up and catch up and add to the discussion anytime you see fit! Even if you don't feel like catching up by reading the missing pages, you can just hop into sparknotes or something and read the chapter summary in there.

Also just because we are on one part of the book doesn't mean you can't comment of previous chapters, or previous book club threads.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
I first found out about this novel because I got a youtube rec with the whole audiobook, here
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQudlUHN7hU


I unironically thought this was a much recent book, 2000s or 2010s because of how similar the themes and characters were to the retard vicissitudes that go in the online political community. When I found out the book was written in the 60s, I was blown away. A red-pilling moment for me. Turns out all of this stupidity has been going on for a long time, and I think one of the ideas of the book is, it will go on forever according to the whims of Fortuna. Funnily enough, this and Gravity's Rainbow shaped my political views more than any Marx or Moldbug, both novels presented a positive view of political detachment, and when I detached myself from politics, it was one of the most liberating experiences in my life.

Of course there's the complaint by awoken people that everything is political and political detachment is white privilege. But eh, if my detachment from politics is just another form of politics then so be it, I will support this political identity.

As for the current 'meta' around the novel, a lot of smartish lit journos like the praise this novel for prediction 4chan. I disagree with that statement for the most part. They like to compare the protagonist to your average 4chan user, and in some ways he is. But in many ways he isn't. I think the most modern equivalent would be someone like MovieBob actually. I'd like to expand on this but I have to withhold spoilers.

Also, to try and level up user engagement and activity, especially since the AK thread was a disaster, I'll try directing the convos more, posting questions and things to talk about. Just to get conversations going

Anyways, I think you guys should read these first few chapters thinking about who does Ignatious reminds you off? And honestly be not afraid to post or name actual youtubers or internet personalities lmao, cause I think that's one of the points of the book. The best thing you can hope to do against such insanity is mocking it. Is satire and mockery a good way to fight political zealotry? What do you guys think?
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

Brapuccino

Active Traveler
Joined
Feb 8, 2023
Messages
195
Reaction score
1,381
Awards
106
Website
www.zeropointfool.com
I like the first cover cause it looks like Mario in the style of Zelda CD lol, but the penguin one is pretty cute.

I loved this book, every line of dialogue from Ignatius was pure gold. Moments of frustration were had reading through Mr Levi's insane wife's shenanigans, and I had a silly grin on my face when Ignatius and Myrna exchanged letters. I appreciate Toole's focus on characters and his ability to clearly define them and keep them alive the whole way through. I feel like the resolution for the secondary characters happened a little hectically but the book's final chapter was a great conclusion for Ignatius character I thought
 

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
I like the first cover cause it looks like Mario in the style of Zelda CD lol, but the penguin one is pretty cute.

I loved this book, every line of dialogue from Ignatius was pure gold. Moments of frustration were had reading through Mr Levi's insane wife's shenanigans, and I had a silly grin on my face when Ignatius and Myrna exchanged letters. I appreciate Toole's focus on characters and his ability to clearly define them and keep them alive the whole way through. I feel like the resolution for the secondary characters happened a little hectically but the book's final chapter was a great conclusion for Ignatius character I thought
The dialogue is gold, especially Ignatius scenes. Still the book often feels too reliant on dialogue ngl, and the Levy scenes felt kinda boring ngl
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

Brapuccino

Active Traveler
Joined
Feb 8, 2023
Messages
195
Reaction score
1,381
Awards
106
Website
www.zeropointfool.com
Still the book often feels too reliant on dialogue ngl
This is probably a big part of why I like it so much, I enjoy the character interactions. For me the weakest part of the book is probably the bar people, the black dude was funny, particularly the attention to detail in his manner of speech, but the rest of the characters involved in that arc were less interesting to me in comparison.
 

Pseudiom

HEARTLAND Neon
Joined
Apr 7, 2023
Messages
13
Reaction score
59
Awards
6
I will likely participate to the best of my ability. I recently bought A Confederacy of Dunces from a book sale. It has been a few months since I have read any long form fiction so I think I'll make use of it. Do not know much about the book beside it is suppose to be incredibly funny and the main character is fat (off to a good start).

I expect contemplation on Catholic themes, the folly of humanity, and extended mockery of intellectuals. I've always imagined it is similar to McCarthy's Suttree, but I expect myself to be wide off mark.
 

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
I will likely participate to the best of my ability. I recently bought A Confederacy of Dunces from a book sale. It has been a few months since I have read any long form fiction so I think I'll make use of it. Do not know much about the book beside it is suppose to be incredibly funny and the main character is fat (off to a good start).

I expect contemplation on Catholic themes, the folly of humanity, and extended mockery of intellectuals. I've always imagined it is similar to McCarthy's Suttree, but I expect myself to be wide off mark.
Suttree is a great comparison actually. Though CD is way less dark and metaphysical depending on how you look at it. Some critics have called Confederancy a cartoon script.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

Brapuccino

Active Traveler
Joined
Feb 8, 2023
Messages
195
Reaction score
1,381
Awards
106
Website
www.zeropointfool.com
I will likely participate to the best of my ability. I recently bought A Confederacy of Dunces from a book sale. It has been a few months since I have read any long form fiction so I think I'll make use of it. Do not know much about the book beside it is suppose to be incredibly funny and the main character is fat (off to a good start).

I expect contemplation on Catholic themes, the foll of humanity, and extended mockery of intellectuals. I've always imagined it is similar to McCarthy's Suttree, but I expect myself to be wide off mark.
not just fat but a fat 30yo virgin living with his mother
 
Love this book so much. Read it like 2 years ago when I moved into a new apartment and had to wait a week for my internet to get installed. Spent that week alternating between replaying the OG Pokemon Red and reading this.

I was a lot more active on /lit/ back then, and it astounded me how Ignatius is the literal embodiment of /lit/. Other than Don Quixote, its probably the only book that literally would make me laugh out loud, and at a consistent basis at that too.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

Pseudiom

HEARTLAND Neon
Joined
Apr 7, 2023
Messages
13
Reaction score
59
Awards
6
Any opinions yet? I'm a bit behind at chapter seven, because I'm juggling a couple of books right now, but I'm enjoying it so far. Toole's prose is nothing extraordinary, but I am loving how he holds nothing sacred and almost every page has produced a chuckle. He is able to tear everything down and knows when to stop right before it turns into outright cruelty. It is one of the few books I feel is a more correct image of reality than reality itself. I think Toole understood how inherently funny most people and their issues are.

Ignatius is honestly... not that bad? I thought he would be a lot more cruel, but, so far, he is more like an overgrown baby with his drawing, inability to finish anything, and odd quirks. Maybe time has made his personality more digestible or, perhaps, more common. I've known people who are worst versions of both sides of his personality: insufferable NEET and failed intellectual. I've only really found the that unique Ignatius combination of both online though—totally unjustified self importance with a gleam of malice. I suppose Ignatius is not either though because he at least has a masters degree and, when push comes to shove (or with a little bullying), Ignatius will get a job no matter how useless he is at it. I assume the slow stockpiling of characters is going to pay off with some explosion at the end—either good or bad, or maybe Theology and Geometry.

I can't deny Toole's talent for sketching characters. The way he introduced Dr. Talc in a few off hand paragraphs was amazing. That description ricocheted through me and I instantly understood who Talc was and his character-thematic relationship to Ignatius's whole cavalcade. I'm more and more interested in who is going to be rolled up into the comedy next.
 

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
Toole's prose is nothing extraordinary, but I am loving how he holds nothing sacred and almost every page has produced a chuckle
The prose is a common criticism and I agree. There's too many adverbs and even a few redundancies. I can't fault it too much since this book wasn't properly edited before release, but still.
. It is one of the few books I feel is a more correct image of reality than reality itself. I think Toole understood how inherently funny most people and their issues are.
Yeah, I love how he decides to make fun of all of these very serious issues. It leaves a lot of room for reflection, since nothing has changed: Confederacy of Dunces is 1950s Woke/Chud cringe compilation. It chooses to thread those who take politics too seriously as the butt of the joke. What is it that draws these deformed characters to political activism? Perhaps it's their need to feel relevant in some way. In the case of Ignatius, it's very clearly a cope for his decadent lifestyle, yet I have to wonder how much he himself is also a product of his time.
I've known people who are worst versions of both sides of his personality: insufferable NEET and failed intellectual.
Yeah, I don't think he's as insufferable as many people think he is. I just think he's pitiful. And a furry. A lot of people ignore that he faps to his childhood dog but--- I'll probably do a dedicated post on why Ignatious isn't really a 4chan troll like so many people seem to think he is.
I can't deny Toole's talent for sketching characters. The way he introduced Dr. Talc in a few off hand paragraphs was amazing. That description ricocheted through me and I instantly understood who Talc was and his character-thematic relationship to Ignatius's whole cavalcade.
Toole is a master of characterization if this books is anything to go by. He was (like me) a very big admirer of Flannery O'connor, I can definitely see the parallels between how Flannery and Toole crafted their characters. Both are Southern writers interested in local custom, and they presented their character as exaggerated, ever-present figures. Flannery for a gothic, grotesque effect and Toole for comedic relief. Either way, its very effective.

Never read his other novel, the Neon Bible.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

remember_summer_days

It ain't Jesus or the devil. It's Jesus or you.
Bronze
Joined
Sep 15, 2021
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
5,889
Awards
301
Why Ignatious O'reilly isn't a 4chan troll.

A lot of modern journos and lit analysts compare O'Reilly to 4chan-esque characters and they praise Toole for predicting the 4chan troll. In the minds of these writers, your average 4chaner is the same thing as a 4chan troll. I believe this view to be mistaken, in fact I highly doubt most 4channers enjoy trolling (at least on 4chan), if anything most 4chan boards are marked by their sincerity and counter culture cultural (with or without merit) creativity. Regardless, wherever 4chan troll or simply and user, I don't believe O'reilly really fits the mold of either.

1. Ignatius has a master degree, he has had an actual prestigious jobs and has accomplishments in life.
2. Ignatius is actually well read. And nevermind how much of a larp his artistic vision is, he has a plan and purpose in life, he's not a cynical, ironic nihilist. And like @Pseudiom pointed out, he's actually willing to get a job.
3. In fact, 4chan would be the exact sort of place Ignatius would call a degenerate abortion. Of course he would still use it even if he hates it, but the impression I get is that most 4channers don't hate 4chan culture.
4. He lacks the self-awareness that most 4channer have. The archetype of a 4chan user is the Underground Man, not that of Ignatius O'reilly. 4channers are too self conscious to have the delusions of grandeur of Ignatius degen imagination.

It's funny to imagine Ignatius using modern 4chan, and he definitely would. But I suspect he would get too triggered by the site's culture and abandon it, except from time to time where he browses /h/ and complains about hacks like Pychon on /lit/. But he wouldn't be a prominent or regular user. Quite honestly, he would be better fit for a website like Kiwifarms, all day contemplating alien degeneracy. (And agoraroad) .
 
Virtual Cafe Awards

Similar threads