With everyone throwing their sorta "conspiracy / non-conspiracy" takes out there... I was gunna do a whole deep-dive wall on a theory I had... but alas, time is scarce... so rather than relegating it to the "maybe one day pile"
(this has been sitting in a word doc since the 20th), here is completely half-baked theory for the sake of possible general interest.
What if Roy Jay was a red herring of sorts. What if all of the controversary surrounding him - and the original comments on /x/ ... were all AI generated.
I have absolutely no proof to back this up
(at the time of writing I'm not even able to load the original thread link to see what the OG date stamps were - Edit: Got it to load... they are all from 2025, so... the possibility is there).
But as a theory - what if this were the pilot of a new form of "AI controversary" marketing.
The premise is simple. Similar to how "rage baiting" became popular on social media - you select something obscure as a "memetic base" - then generate AI comments to create "buzz" and form an artificial "social circle" around the "base". This "circle of controversy" attracts attention from real human users, and is the first stage in the
AIDA model of marketing.
Now who - or why, would anyone do this? I scribbled down some possibilities:
•
Local Government - Demolishes mass anonymous communication, because anonymous comments can no longer be verified or trusted by anyone. Governments love this because they hate privacy
(they try to make things like privacy coins illegal, try to get everyone to use ID to use the internet, etc.). By invalidating the credibility of anonymous communication channels, the government gains an angle for mass social compliance with new privacy regulations.
•
Foreign Government - Same purpose as above, but with the intent to disrupt a nation's internal communication channels with false signals that elicit controlled and predictable behaviors to later exploit.
•
Marketers - No first or third party data needed - entirely behavioral based. If the behavior is predictable
(and they can leverage AI "social circles" to elicit controlled human behavioral responses), they can target that synthesized behavioral pattern, rather than any demographic group or personified individual. This is very cost efficient.
•
Rogue Actors - They don't need a reason. Sewing chaos is its own reward - a source of entertainment for themselves, and an ability to exercise control over what others do.
Don't get me wrong, I sorta like Jay. Quirky act. And we've sort of integrated him into our culture
(the Roy Jay pogs Punp made look awesome).
But one day randomly in the shower, the idea popped into my head - "what if Roy were almost like an AI 'culture virus' that crept its way into our 'system'... like a 'trojan horse' of sorts... we bring in the 'object of interest' to investigate, and make memes out of it that integrate with our culture, only to slowly have our culture 'infected' by AI... like 'drinking from a poison well' and slowly becoming sick..."
For the time being? It seems harmless and an isolated case. But I figured there may be some value in at least presenting the concept to raise collective mental vigilance in the event that any such tactic ever does become a reality / more widely implemented.