Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet

A toplist is a single web page on which thematically similar external websites are linked in the form of text and/or advertising banners. It serves as a collection of links for visitors and is intended to list the best external websites in descending order according to their ranking. Toplists were popular in the early 2000s and there was a toplist for every niche hobby.

This is a screenshot from a now defunct German anime toplist from 2005

Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 9


This is a still an active toplist

Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 10


Toplists exist still today but lead a fringe existence. However, they seem to be the gate to a forgotten or hidden internet. There seem to be two kinds of toplists today: a toplist of toplists where people create (relatively new) toplists that link to other toplists; and there are toplists that actually link to interesting sites. These sites are either webpages that are long forgotten and relicts of the past

For example, we have the webpage of the Nachteulen Duesseldorf, a German darts club (which also have their own Darts-related toplist)
Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 1


Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 2


You have also webpages that look like they came from the early 2000s, but are relatively fresh and actively updated such as this joke website
Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 3


Or this page about herbs, which has another whole fucking subpage dedicated to religion, where people even still post in the guestbooks
Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 4

Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 5

Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 6


There are even communities that are relatively new but still feel like they came from the early 2000s, for example Ebbes Freundschaftsforum where people still actively post daily
Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 7


Or this general free-for-all forum where people talk about everything or play games
Toplists: A window to the old (not so dead) internet, image 8


I think the most interesting part is that those pages don't feel like a bad simulation like, for example, Neocities but genuinely feel like they are stuck in time.
 
This is a fascinating read, thanks for sharing. Can anyone make a toplist? Are they always at the top of the domain, or are they subpages of existing websites? Is having a toplist the main reason for a website?

You also mentioned a radio internet on your profile. That would be another excellent post.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards
In 2003-2013 I led and participated in several RP forums. There were a couple sites that hosted toplists (we called them topsites) where RP forums were able to submit their site to the list and get upvoted based on people clicking through. It was pretty common for there to be some kind of in-game incentive offered for people who clicked on your site through the toplist/topsite.

It was all a way for people to find popular and active forums. This was especially important because forum admins didn't have control over SEO like they do now.

Edit: looks like the only topsite that exists anymore is https://www.toprpsites.com/
 
Last edited:
In 2003-2013 I led and participated in several RP forums. There were a couple sites that hosted toplists (we called them topsites) where RP forums were able to submit their site to the list and get upvoted based on people clicking through. It was pretty common for there to be some kind of in-game incentive offered for people who clicked on your site through the toplist/topsite.

It was all a way for people to find popular and active forums. This was especially important because forum admins didn't have control over SEO like they do now.

Edit: looks like the only topsite that exists anymore is https://www.toprpsites.com/
Oh damn now you say this it's electroshocked my memory - there was a topsites page for MUD games which was constantly at war for the top slot. I feel like it was vote based and you'd get in-game currency for voting for the game. It was very biased.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards
Agora road toplist when?

this would be a fantastic gateway into the indie web and give the site a better connection to the rest of the space. yes, we already have a webring and users that advertise their own personal sites, but the more the merrier, i say.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards
Agora road toplist when?

this would be a fantastic gateway into the indie web and give the site a better connection to the rest of the space. yes, we already have a webring and users that advertise their own personal sites, but the more the merrier, i say.
I started writing a shitpost about pogs before I realised I actually do know a lot about good websites for pogs. Going to write a list on my site.
 
Virtual Cafe Awards
This is a fascinating read, thanks for sharing. Can anyone make a toplist? Are they always at the top of the domain, or are they subpages of existing websites? Is having a toplist the main reason for a website?

You also mentioned a radio internet on your profile. That would be another excellent post.

I guess anyone can make a toplist, in theory. I'm not sure if there are any open-source toplists for self-hosting. The ones I saw are mostly by service providers where you can create your own toplist page. But this is something that could be fixed :)

There are webpages that are dedicated only to the toplist, i.e. contain only a toplist. However, I know from back in the day that a lot of pages and communities dedicated to niche hobbies had also their own toplist as a subpage.

Regarding the radio internet, maybe I can do this when I have my license for amateur radio operation

Agora road toplist when?

this would be a fantastic gateway into the indie web and give the site a better connection to the rest of the space. yes, we already have a webring and users that advertise their own personal sites, but the more the merrier,
Yeah, I think toplists would be a nice addition to webrings. I think that pages from the indie web may even be more discoverable. I think that a modern toplist would be superior to current-year search engines, as the probability is higher that you find pages that aren't SEO'd to death and you could have topic specific toplists.
 
A toplist is a single web page on which thematically similar external websites are linked in the form of text and/or advertising banners. It serves as a collection of links for visitors and is intended to list the best external websites in descending order according to their ranking. Toplists were popular in the early 2000s and there was a toplist for every niche hobby.

This is a screenshot from a now defunct German anime toplist from 2005

View attachment 155890

This is a still an active toplist

View attachment 155892

Toplists exist still today but lead a fringe existence. However, they seem to be the gate to a forgotten or hidden internet. There seem to be two kinds of toplists today: a toplist of toplists where people create (relatively new) toplists that link to other toplists; and there are toplists that actually link to interesting sites. These sites are either webpages that are long forgotten and relicts of the past

For example, we have the webpage of the Nachteulen Duesseldorf, a German darts club (which also have their own Darts-related toplist)
View attachment 155867

View attachment 155869

You have also webpages that look like they came from the early 2000s, but are relatively fresh and actively updated such as this joke website
View attachment 155872

Or this page about herbs, which has another whole fucking subpage dedicated to religion, where people even still post in the guestbooks
View attachment 155874
View attachment 155875
View attachment 155877

There are even communities that are relatively new but still feel like they came from the early 2000s, for example Ebbes Freundschaftsforum where people still actively post daily
View attachment 155879

Or this general free-for-all forum where people talk about everything or play games
View attachment 155880

I think the most interesting part is that those pages don't feel like a bad simulation like, for example, Neocities but genuinely feel like they are stuck in time.
This is perfect whilst listening to Freddie Dredd Witness
 
Virtual Cafe Awards
badge